How I Met Your Mother is quite good at giving it’s fans amazingly happy, and emotional moments that make us feel all warm and fuzzy inside, and the last two episodes of season 9 were definitely not disappointing in this area.
In episode 20, which aired on March 10, Marshall learned of Lily’s second pregnancy, and quickly becomes frantic about the idea of everything they need to do before the baby is born — including researching schools in Italy. When Lily protests that they aren’t going to Italy, Marshall tells her otherwise in a typically “Aweee” fashion.
“Of course we are. Lily, we have to do this. You’re gonna live in Rome, and you’re gonna get your dream, because you’re giving me mine — again.”
At the end of the episode, we were offered a glimpse of Ted and the mother’s first date — and first kiss — and it made (most of) us so, so happy. It also got me thinking about all of the other HIMYM moments that put joy in my heart, and a big grin on my face. So I figured, with the end of the series fast approaching, what better way to commemorate one of my favourite shows than with a blog post.
So, here it is — my top 5 heartwarming HIMYM moments.
5. Mickey Comes Through — “Tailgate,” season 7, episode 13
Let’s be honest. Lily’s father, Mickey, is no one’s favourite character. And those feelings of dislike temporarily reached a peak when Lily reluctantly called Mickey to tell him she was pregnant, and his only response was a nonchalant “That’s great,” before he hangs up.
What we don’t know until the end of the episode is that, as soon as he heard the news, Mickey drove all the way to New York from a board game convention in Chicago to be with his daughter. He arrives at her doorstep, holding a giant teddy bear, and is rewarded by a hug from a teary-eyed Lily, and the regained respect of us — the audience.
(SIDE NOTE: This episode was also heart-warming because of the scenes featuring Marshall “tailgating” at his father’s grave, but since I’ve included another Marvin moment in my list, Mickey gets the #5 spot.)
4. Barney Goes to San Francisco — “Bachelor Party,” season 2, episode 19
We all know that Barney has a particular fondness for strippers, and he definitely believes that no bachelor party is complete without one. So, despite Marshall’s insistence that he doesn’t want a stripper at his bachelor party, Barney hires one anyways. The stripper breaks her ankle in the guys’ hotel room, and they are all eventually kicked out after Barney’s lit cigar starts a fire. Essentially, Barney’s stripper ruined the awesome bachelor party that was carefully planned by best man Ted.
After Lily’s bridal shower, her and Robin head to the bar, where they are surprised to run into Ted and Marshall. After telling them about the bachelor party fiasco, Marshall says that he is so upset with Barney that he is considering not even inviting him to the wedding. Lily won’t stand for this, and tells a story that reveals to us that she and Marshall may not even be having a wedding if it weren’t for Barney.
Barney, being unable to continue seeing Marshall so depressed over losing Lily, flew to San Francisco. There, he told Lily that she should come back to New York, because she and Marshall are meant to be together. And, because we all know Barney is sweet in his own special way, he also tells Lily that he can’t keep stealing girls from Marshall forever.
Marshall is so happy to discover how much Barney cares about him and Lily, he makes Barney his co-best man.
3. Barney Brings Canada to Robin — “The Rehearsal Dinner,” season 9, episode 12
I chose this moment as my third favourite, partly because it was just so adorable, and partly because, like Robin, I am just so proud to be Canadian. (My birthday is on July 1, after all.)
During the episode, it’s revealed to us that, although Robin hoped to get married in Canada, she compromised, and agreed to get married in New York instead. She tells Barney that, because she made this compromise, he must agree to have a “normal” rehearsal dinner. He agrees, but he has a trick up his sleeve.
For most of the episode, Barney plays it like he thinks Robin is going to surprise him with an awesome laser tag rehearsal dinner, but it’s actually him that has a surprise planned. He even makes an excuse to go to the laser tag arena, and Robin follows him there (where he has ended up in the security office.)
Barney tells Robin that he can’t promise he will never lie to her, if lying means preventing her from finding out about a surprise. On cue, snow begins to fall in the office. With the press of a button, the walls of the “office” raise to reveal an ice rink full of family, and friends, and decorated with red and white balloons, and streamers. Barney presents Robin with a signed picture of Wayne Gretzky as a wedding gift, and Ted falls on his face during an attempt to skate. It’s a winning combo in more ways than one.
2. “Symphony of Illumination” — season 7, episode 12
Robin and Ted have numerous heartwarming moments, but this one beats them all, because it focused on their friendship, and not a romance between them.
During this episode — which opens with Robin telling her kids how she met their father — my heart absolutely broke for Robin. Her period is a week late, and she assumes that she is pregnant (with Barney’s baby). She makes a doctors appointment to find out, and she and Barney are both relieved when the results are negative. Robin celebrates this fact, until she receives more news from her doctor — she us unable to have children. Ever.
Rather than tell her friends the news, Robin says she is disappointed because she has just found out she didn’t make the Canadian pole-vaulting team.
The gang notices Robin acting strangely, and when Ted presses her to tell him why, Robin snaps at him, telling him he shouldn’t feel responsible for cheering her up. Robin takes a walk in Central Park, and it is revealed that the kids she spoke to in the beginning of the episode never existed.
When Robin returns to her and Ted’s apartment, Robin discovers a very elaborate, very bright, and very AC/DC Christmas light display, which Ted has lovingly constructed. Ted tells her that she doesn’t have to tell him why she’s upset, but that he will never stop trying to cheer her up. Robin breaks down into tears, and the two friends hug.
Future Ted tells his kids that, although Robin never had children, she became a famous journalist, traveled the world, and even had a stint as a bullfighter. But there was one thing Ted said Robin never was …
1. ‘I Love You Son’ — “Last Words,” season 6, episode 14
Marshall’s relationship with his dad, Marvin, was repeatedly a source of many chuckles throughout the series. Even “Bad News,” the episode in which Marvin dies, was humorous until near the end. This only served to make the news of Marvin’s death — and Marshall’s heartbreaking reaction to it — even more devastating. Thus far, that episode is the single saddest of the series. And, for the first while, it seemed like “Last Words” was heading in the same direction.
The episode takes place at Marvin’s funeral, in Marshall’s hometown of St. Cloud, Minnesota. Marshall’s high school bully, Trey, who is leading the service, tells Marshall and his family that Marvin’s last words to them should be a theme during the service.
Marshall’s mother and brothers discuss Marvin’s last words to them, and each story is more touching than the last. Marshall is hesitant to share the last conversation he had with his father, which was rather trivial, and neither touching, nor inspirational.
When Marshall charges his cellphone for the first time since before Marvin’s death, he discovers a voicemail from his father. Marshall initially decides not to listen to the message, but during the service, he heads outside to check it.
At first, the message is only static and scratching — the sounds of a pocket dial. Marshall is outraged, and begins a heartbreaking speech to his friends about how his father meant so much to him, and how unfair it is that Marvin’s last words to him were nothing but a pocket dial.Suddenly, Marvin’s voice begins speaking through the phone. He apologizes for the pocket dial, and tells Marshall that he loves him, and goodbye. (This is followed by Marvin asking Marshall for his foot cream, but the gang decides to ignore that — Marvin’s last words to Marshall were “I love you, son.”)
So, that’s my list. What about you guys? What are your favourite HIMYM moments? Let me know in the comments!